Introduction
Brooks is well known for its reliable, well-fitting daily trainers, which sell in large numbers. However, the brand has struggled to make a strong impact in the racing category. Last year, the “standard” Brooks Hyperion Elite 4 was released but received a lukewarm reception, largely due to the absence of a super foam – a feature now standard in most modern super shoes. Fortunately, that has changed with the introduction of PEBA in this update, while the rest of the shoe remains unchanged. But is this enough to make it a true competitor in the super shoe market? Let’s dive in and find out.
The new version offers an almost invisible fit
Ivan: One area where Brooks consistently excels is the fit of its uppers. Comfort has always been one of the brand’s strongest selling points, and while it may not be the top priority in the racing category, expectations remain high for Brooks in this regard. Thankfully, they’ve retained the same upper in the Hyperion Elite 4 PB. The knit material is exceptionally soft and breathable, providing a comfortable and plush feel.
However, my sample pair runs noticeably long and slightly too spacious overall. I suspect this is a production anomaly, as I haven’t seen others report the same issue. Fortunately, I was able to resolve it with thicker socks and a heel lock, though going a half-size down would likely have provided a perfect fit.
The tongue is thin but well-padded, featuring a small strip at the top to prevent lace bite. The shoe also includes textured laces and padded strips in the heel, similar to many premium racing shoes, ensuring a secure lockdown. Overall, the upper delivers a highly comfortable experience – so comfortable, in fact, that you barely notice it while running, which is exactly what most runners prefer.
A new and improved foam gives a ride which may not suit all styles
Ivan: The introduction of DNA Gold, Brooks’ first PEBA-based midsole compound, is the true game-changer in the Hyperion Elite 4 PB – and the only notable update. With nearly every other supershoe on the market incorporating some form of superfoam, this change was both expected and a welcome step forward for Brooks.
So, how does it affect the ride? It’s noticeably softer and bouncier than its predecessor but still delivers a more “natural” ride compared to most supershoes. For better or worse, the shoe lacks a pronounced rocker, and its SpeedVault Race+ carbon plate with cutouts seems to prioritize stability over propulsion. This results in a ride that feels lower to the ground and more controlled than many of its competitors.
The foam feels noticeably softer for heel strikers, hinting at a potential variation in midsole density in the rear. With an 8mm drop and a stable platform, the Hyperion Elite 4 PB appears to be a dream shoe for heel strikers who enjoy a snappy, controlled ride that still maintains a natural feel. Midfoot and forefoot strikers, however, may find it lacking in that ultra-bouncy or squishy sensation common in many supershoes. Instead, it offers a more traditional racing shoe feel with a touch of modern snappiness.
For efficient heel strikers, the Hyperion Elite 4 PB could work all the way up to the marathon distance, while others may find it better suited for shorter races, uptempo workouts, track intervals, and hill repeats. Personally, I think a more pronounced rocker would have complemented my flatter midfoot strike, as the forefoot can feel a bit thin at times.
Ultimately, it all comes down to running style and personal preference. That said, I find it refreshing that not every modern supershoe is excessively soft, unstable, and completely lacking ground feel.
The outsole offers some great grip
Ivan: The outsole of the Brooks Hyperion Elite 4 PB almost mirrors the plate’s design, featuring cutouts that expose the midsole. However, coverage is sufficient, and I’ve noticed no significant wear so far – aside from a few minor dents from gravel pressing into the exposed foam. Thankfully, this doesn’t seem to impact long-term performance or durability.
Grip has been excellent, even outperforming most other race-day shoes on a frosty morning at the track. Overall, the outsole provides a solid balance of durability and traction, ensuring reliable performance across various conditions.
How much of an upgrade do we get here?
Ivan: I’m confident that most runners will see the Brooks Hyperion Elite 4 PB as a significant upgrade, thanks to the introduction of the PEBA-based ‘DNA Flash’ midsole. At the same time, many will appreciate that the rest of the shoe remains unchanged, as both the upper and outsole are exceptionally well-constructed and among the best in the race-day category.
When it comes to the ride, the Hyperion Elite 4 PB is noticeably more forgiving than its predecessor. However, while it remains stable and snappy, those looking for a squishy, rockered, and highly propulsive experience may want to look elsewhere. That said, efficient heel strikers will likely benefit from the added heel cushioning, and runners who prefer a more traditional feel – while still taking advantage of modern foam technology – will find plenty to like.
